Key facts
- Staffing companies turned over their temporary and contract workforce at an annual rate of 414% in 2023, and the average temp worker stayed 10.1 weeks, according to the American Staffing Association’s turnover and tenure data.
- Industrial jobs are the largest segment of the staffing industry, at 36% of staffing employment, according to the ASA’s staffing industry statistics.
- U.S. temporary help services employment was 2,486,800 in September 2026, which is 674,600 jobs (21%) below its March 2022 peak of 3,161,400, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data published by FRED.
- Industrial staffing hours were up 15% year over year in late September 2026, according to the SIA | Bullhorn Staffing Indicator.
- EB-3 visas for “Other Workers” (unskilled roles) are capped at 10,000 per year, according to the U.S. State Department’s October 2026 Visa Bulletin.
The turnover numbers industrial staffing firms deal with every year
For most employers, replacing their entire workforce once in a year would be alarming. In staffing, replacing it once would be far below the norm. The American Staffing Association reports that temporary and contract employee turnover was 414% in 2023, only slightly better than the 419% recorded in 2022. In practical terms, a staffing firm’s temporary workforce is replaced several times over in a single year, and the recruiting, onboarding and safety training that go with each replacement have to be repeated each time.

The ASA’s tenure figure makes the same point more concretely. The average temp or contract employee stayed on the job for 10.1 weeks in 2023, up only marginally from 10.0 weeks in 2022. That is about two and a half months. A worker placed on a warehouse dock or production line in January is, on average, gone before spring, and the agency has to find, screen and place someone new to keep the client’s order filled.
It helps to know how the ASA measures this, because the method explains why the numbers are so high. As described on the ASA’s turnover and tenure page, turnover equals total W-2s issued during the year divided by average weekly employment, multiplied by 100, minus 100. Every person who receives a paycheck from the agency during the year counts, even if they worked only a few days. The method doesn’t inflate the problem. It measures exactly the volume of hiring and paperwork an agency has to carry to keep its seats filled.
The ASA’s broader staffing statistics show the same pattern at the scale of the entire industry. Staffing companies employed about 11 million temporary and contract workers over the course of 2024, yet only about 2.2 million were working in an average week. The industry also hired 12.7 million temporary and contract employees during 2023. Those numbers describe a business model where recruiting is not a support function but the central, never-ending operational cost.
Why industrial staffing feels the turnover problem most
Industrial work is the single largest part of the staffing industry. The ASA reports that industrial roles account for 36% of staffing employment, ahead of office-clerical and administrative work at 24% and professional-managerial work at 21%. When the industry-wide turnover rate is above 400%, the segment with the most workers is the one handling the largest volume of replacements.
The jobs themselves explain a lot of the churn. The BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook lists hand laborers and material movers as requiring no formal educational credential and no related work experience. On-the-job training typically lasts a month or less. Those low barriers are what make the roles fillable through a staffing agency in the first place, but they also mean workers can leave for a similar job down the road with very little to lose.
Pay is another factor. BLS reports that hand laborers and material movers earned a median wage of $18.38 an hour, or $38,220 a year, in May 2025. The work is physical and repetitive, and it often takes place on warehouse floors and production lines rather than in climate-controlled offices. When a nearby employer offers a little more per hour or a better schedule, a temp worker who has been on assignment for a few weeks has every incentive to move.
The occupation is also enormous, which keeps competition for workers intense. BLS counts 6,917,800 hand laborer and material mover jobs as of 2025, and projects about 904,200 openings per year through 2035. Most of those openings come from replacing workers who change occupations or leave the labor force, not from new positions. Staffing firms compete for that same replacement flow against warehouses, retailers, manufacturers and distributors that are hiring directly.
Staffing firms carry a meaningful share of this workforce. BLS reports that the administrative and support services sector, which includes staffing agencies, employs 11% of all hand laborers and material movers. That places industrial staffing firms in direct competition with their own clients, who are often trying to hire the same people for permanent roles.
The temp workforce is 675,000 smaller than it was in 2022
High turnover would be easier to manage if the pool of temp workers were growing. It isn’t. BLS data, via the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis’s FRED database, shows that the U.S. temp help workforce peaked at 3,161,400 in March 2022. By September 2026 it stood at 2,486,800, a decline of 674,600 jobs, or about 21%.
This is the core of the industrial staffing labor shortage. Firms that once had a deep bench of workers who knew the agency, had passed screening and could be dispatched on short notice now have a noticeably thinner one. With average tenure at about ten weeks, every placement that ends has to be refilled from a smaller group of people who are already on the agency’s payroll, or from new applicants who have to be recruited, screened and onboarded from scratch.
The decline was steady for most of the period. Temp help employment fell through 2023, 2024 and 2025, reaching a low of 2,451,400 in December 2025. It then recovered in the first half of 2026, adding 56,100 jobs to reach 2,507,500 in June. That rebound did not last, and temp help employment fell by 20,700 jobs between July and September 2026.
The most recent month shows the same direction. The BLS Employment Situation report for September 2026, released on October 2, shows temp help services losing about 10,900 jobs in September alone. The workforce remains far below where it was four years ago, and the 2026 rebound has already partly reversed.
| Period | Temp help services employment | Change |
|---|---|---|
| March 2022 (peak) | 3,161,400 | None |
| December 2025 (low) | 2,451,400 | -710,000 from peak |
| June 2026 | 2,507,500 | +56,100 from December 2025 |
| September 2026 (preliminary) | 2,486,800 | -20,700 from June 2026 |
| Total change, March 2022 to September 2026 | -674,600 (-21%) |
It is worth being precise about what this number measures, because precision is what makes the story credible. The BLS series counts people on temporary help agency payrolls, not job openings or unfilled orders. Part of the decline since 2022 likely reflects clients ordering fewer temps as hiring cooled, so it should not be read as a count of unfilled jobs. What it means for an industrial staffing firm, however, is clear: there are far fewer experienced temp workers in the system than there were in 2022, so each new order has to be filled from a smaller pool.
Client demand for industrial workers is coming back
The pressure is building on the demand side as well. The SIA | Bullhorn Staffing Indicator, an index built from activity on the Bullhorn staffing software platform, reported that industrial staffing hours were up 15% year over year for the week ending September 26, 2026. Industrial workers on assignment averaged 36.6 hours a week. Staffing Industry Analysts said industrial hours had shown an “impressive ramp” starting in late April and continuing through September.
SIA attributed that growth to manufacturing and logistics clients, along with work connected to data center construction and operations. It also noted that industrial indicator levels were higher than at the same point one, two and three years earlier. Because the indicator is based on platform data rather than a government survey, it is best read as a signal of direction rather than an official count, but the direction is clearly up.
The broader staffing market points the same way, though more modestly. The ASA Staffing Index showed staffing employment up 3.3% year over year for the week of September 7-13, 2026. Even the BLS series, despite its recent monthly losses, put September 2026 temp help employment slightly above the September 2025 level of 2,471,600. Demand is not booming everywhere, but it has stopped shrinking and, for industrial work, it is clearly growing.
Growth is happening under real constraints. In a July 2026 index update, ASA chief economist Noah Yosif said that “rising cost pressures and economic uncertainty continue to stifle further gains in temporary employment.” Clients want more industrial workers, but they are also watching their budgets, which limits how much of the recruiting cost staffing firms can pass on through higher bill rates.
The Industrial Staffing Trilemma
Industrial staffing agencies are currently operating in a structurally constrained market defined by three colliding forces. When combined, these factors create what market analysts call The Industrial Staffing Trilemma:
- Extreme Worker Churn (414% Annual Turnover): Agency workforces are replaced nearly four times per year, with average assignment tenure lasting just 10.1 weeks.
- A Shrinking Talent Bench (-21% Supply): The U.S. temporary help workforce has lost 674,600 workers since its 2022 peak, drastically reducing the pool of available talent.
- Resurgent Client Demand (+15% Hours Worked): Client orders in manufacturing, logistics, and infrastructure continue to grow, forcing agencies to stretch fewer workers across more billable hours.
| Force | Market Metric | Operational Impact |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Hyper-Turnover | 414% annual turnover / 10.1 weeks avg. tenure | Endless cycle of onboarding, safety training, and administrative costs. |
| 2. Contracted Bench | 2,486,800 temp workers (down 21% vs. 2022) | Fewer pre-screened, experienced workers available for rapid deployment. |
| 3. Rising Demand | +15% YoY industrial staffing hours worked | Existing workers are pushed into overtime to meet client order capacity. |
Why the Trilemma Breaks Traditional Operating Models
Under normal conditions, an agency can absorb high turnover if the candidate pool is growing. Conversely, an agency can manage a tight labor pool if client demand remains flat.
However, when client demand rises while the candidate bench shrinks, recruiting capacity becomes trapped in a loop, spending resources repeatedly refilling the same high-turnover roles rather than expanding market share or filling specialized positions.
Industrial staffing labor snapshot
| Metric | Figure | Source and date |
|---|---|---|
| Annual temp/contract turnover | 414% | ASA, 2023 |
| Average temp/contract tenure | 10.1 weeks | ASA, 2023 |
| Industrial share of staffing employment | 36% | ASA |
| Temp/contract workers employed during the year | About 11 million | ASA, 2024 |
| Temp/contract workers in an average week | About 2.2 million | ASA, 2024 |
| Temp help services employment | 2,486,800 | BLS, September 2026 (preliminary) |
| Change from March 2022 peak | −674,600 (−21%) | BLS |
| Industrial staffing hours, year over year | +15% | SIA/Bullhorn, week ending Sept. 26, 2026 |
| Hand laborer and material mover median wage | $18.38/hour | BLS, May 2025 |
| Projected annual hand laborer openings | 904,200 per year through 2035 | BLS |
Who fills industrial staffing jobs
The industrial temp workforce is concentrated in a few physical, entry-level occupations. According to the BLS Contingent and Alternative Employment Arrangements release, production, transportation and material moving occupations made up about one in four temporary help agency workers in July 2023, the most recent survey available. These are the forklift operators, pickers, packers, line workers and general laborers who make up the core of industrial staffing orders.
The same survey offers a useful clue about retention. In Table 9 of the release, 27.7% of temporary help agency workers said they would prefer a different work arrangement, while 48.2% preferred their temp arrangement and 18.4% said it depends. More than a quarter of the temp workforce, in other words, is open to something more permanent. Those workers are prime candidates to leave an assignment the moment a direct-hire offer comes along, which is one of the forces behind the industry’s high turnover.
For staffing firms, that preference is both a risk and an opportunity. Workers who want stability will leave temp assignments to find it elsewhere if the agency can’t offer a path to it. Firms that can offer longer assignments, temp-to-hire conversions or permanent employment with the agency itself have a better chance of keeping their best workers instead of training them for a competitor.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the turnover rate for temporary staffing employees?
The American Staffing Association reports that annual turnover among temporary and contract employees was 414% in 2023, compared with 419% in 2022. The ASA calculates turnover by dividing total W-2s issued during the year by average weekly employment, multiplying by 100 and subtracting 100. A rate above 400% means a staffing firm’s temporary workforce was replaced several times over during the year, which is why recruiting never stops in this business.
Is there a labor shortage in industrial staffing in 2026?
Industrial staffing firms face a tighter labor supply than they did a few years ago. BLS data shows temp help services employment at 2,486,800 in September 2026, about 674,600 jobs or 21% below its March 2022 peak. At the same time, the SIA | Bullhorn Staffing Indicator showed industrial staffing hours up 15% year over year in late September 2026, so firms are trying to fill more hours from a smaller temp workforce while still replacing workers at a rate above 400% a year.
Why is temp help employment falling if industrial demand is rising?
The two measures track different things. BLS counts the number of people on temp agency payrolls, which is still well below its 2022 peak and fell by 20,700 between July and September 2026. The SIA | Bullhorn indicator tracks hours worked on industrial assignments, which rose 15% year over year, with workers averaging 36.6 hours a week. Read together, they suggest that some of the rising demand may be met by existing workers putting in more hours rather than by adding people.
How long does the average temp assignment last?
The ASA reports that the average tenure of a temporary or contract employee was 10.1 weeks in 2023, up slightly from 10.0 weeks in 2022. That is roughly two and a half months. For industrial clients, it means a temp-staffed position can see several different workers over a single year, each needing orientation and safety training.
Can a staffing agency sponsor workers for an EB-3 green card?
A staffing agency can file a PERM labor certification, which is the first step toward EB-3 sponsorship, if it is the actual employer and has a genuine permanent job to offer. The Department of Labor’s PERM frequently asked questions addresses staffing agencies directly. When the future worksite is unknown and the agency has clients, the job notice must be posted at each current client’s worksite, and the prevailing wage is based on the area of the agency’s headquarters. If the agency has no clients, DOL says the application would be denied because there is no real job opportunity.
How long does EB-3 sponsorship take for unskilled workers?
The timeline has several stages, and each one adds time. The Department of Labor’s processing times page showed PERM applications in analyst review averaging 336 days as of August 2026, with December 2025 filings being processed. After certification, unskilled workers are subject to the State Department’s visa bulletin: in October 2026, the EB-3 Other Workers final action date for most countries was January 1, 2022.
What This Means for Industrial Staffing Firms
The data points to one central problem, constant replacement of workers from a smaller pool, and the most effective responses address it from several directions at once. None of the options below is a complete solution on its own. Firms that combine short-term fixes with a longer-term plan for a permanent core workforce are in the best position for the demand growth that industrial clients are signaling.
1. Measure temp turnover the way the industry does. Use the ASA formula of total W-2s divided by average weekly employment, times 100, minus 100, and track it separately from internal staff turnover. Measuring it by branch, client and job type shows where the 400%-plus churn is concentrated. A firm that knows which accounts burn through workers fastest can target its retention spending where it will have the most effect.
2. Build the cost of churn into client pricing. With 12.7 million temp and contract hires across the industry in 2023, recruiting is a core cost of the business, not overhead. Firms that track recruiting and onboarding cost per placement can show clients what high-turnover assignments actually cost. That makes it easier to negotiate bill rates, minimum assignment lengths or conversion fees that reflect the real work of keeping a position filled.
3. Compete on pay and schedules where the data supports it. BLS puts the median wage for hand laborers and material movers at $18.38 an hour, and staffing firms compete for those workers against warehouses, retailers and manufacturers hiring directly. Comparing your pay rates against local benchmarks, and offering predictable shifts where possible, gives workers fewer reasons to leave for a job across the street. It also helps to watch hours closely, since industrial temp workers already average 36.6 hours a week on physically demanding jobs.
4. Turn temp-to-hire into a retention tool. BLS survey data shows that 27.7% of temp help agency workers would prefer a different arrangement. Offering a clear path to permanent employment, either with the client or with the agency itself, gives those workers a reason to stay instead of leaving for the first direct-hire offer they see. Agencies that keep a core of long-tenure workers spend less time refilling the same positions.
5. Use EB-3 sponsorship to build a permanent core workforce. EB-3 sponsorship addresses the core problem in this data directly: workers who arrive through the program come for a permanent, full-time job, not a 10-week assignment. For firms with steady, long-term industrial client demand, sponsored workers can form a stable core that reduces the constant cycle of recruiting and replacement. The program has clear requirements and limits. The agency must be the actual employer and offer a genuine permanent position. The job must be posted at each current client worksite, with the wage based on the headquarters area. EB-3 is built for firms that plan ahead. The Other Workers category currently has 10,000 visas a year, and PERM analyst review averaged 336 days as of August 2026, so most firms treat EB-3 as a two-to-three-year pipeline rather than a quick fill. Firms that start now, with steady clients and a clear picture of the roles they need, can have a permanent, trained core workforce in place while competitors are still refilling the same positions every ten weeks.
Congress is also considering changes that would make EB-3 an even stronger option for industrial employers. The Dignity Act of 2025 (H.R. 4393) is a bipartisan bill introduced on July 15, 2025, by Reps. María Elvira Salazar (R-FL) and Veronica Escobar (D-TX), and it had 35 cosponsors as of January 2026. Its most important change for unskilled workers is simple: spouses and minor children would no longer count against annual visa totals. Today, every family member who immigrates with a sponsored worker uses a number from the same annual limit. The bill leaves the 10,000 Other Workers cap in place, but more of those visas would go to the workers employers actually sponsor. It would also raise the per-country limit on preference visas from 7% to 15%, and fund visa processing with $225 million for the Department of Labor’s Office of Foreign Labor Certification, which handles PERM, and $2.56 billion for USCIS. For employers, that would mean more workers per year and shorter, more predictable timelines. The bill has not become law, and today’s rules still apply, but eb3.work’s Dignity Act page explains the proposal and how employers can support it.
Sources
- American Staffing Association, Temp Turnover and Tenure, 2003–2023
- American Staffing Association, Staffing Industry Statistics
- American Staffing Association, ASA Staffing Index
- American Staffing Association, Staffing Index Grows in July (July 28, 2026)
- Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED), All Employees, Temporary Help Services (TEMPHELPS), source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, The Employment Situation – September 2026 (October 2, 2026)
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Hand Laborers and Material Movers
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Contingent and Alternative Employment Arrangements – July 2023 (November 8, 2024)
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Table 9: Preference for arrangement by contingent status and alternative work arrangement, July 2023
- Staffing Industry Analysts, SIA | Bullhorn Staffing Indicator – October 6, 2026
- U.S. Department of Labor, Office of Foreign Labor Certification, PERM and Prevailing Wage Processing Times
- U.S. Department of Labor, PERM Frequently Asked Questions







